West Milford Housing Guide

Real Estate

West Milford's housing market is shaped by lakes, wooded hills, rural roads and environmental constraints. The township includes everything from smaller converted summer cottages and lakefront homes to larger houses on acreage, condos and private lake communities.

Market-data note: Sale prices, listing prices and automated home-value indexes are different measures. The dated figures below provide market context rather than an appraisal of a specific property.

2026 market snapshot

IndicatorRecent measurePeriod / source
Typical home value$504,537Zillow, July 31, 2026
Typical-value change+3.5% year over yearZillow, July 31, 2026
Median list price$488,000Zillow, July 31, 2026
Median sold price$505,912Realtor.com, August 2026
Median listing price$473,725Realtor.com, August 2026
Median listing price per sq. ft.$235Realtor.com, August 2026
Active listings211Realtor.com, August 2026
Median rent$2,850/monthRealtor.com, August 2026

Buying in West Milford: local due diligence

Lake associations

Many lake neighborhoods have private associations, annual dues, beach/boating rules or membership requirements. Verify rights and obligations for the specific property.

Highlands restrictions

The township sits entirely within the Highlands Preservation Area. Additions, new construction, septic work and land disturbance can involve environmental and water-protection requirements.

Septic & wells

Private septic and well systems are common. Review age, condition, permits, testing and future replacement costs rather than assuming public utility service.

Flood & drainage

Lakes, reservoirs, streams and steep terrain make parcel-level flood and drainage review important, especially around waterfront and low-lying properties.

Private / narrow roads

Some lake and mountain neighborhoods have narrow or privately maintained roads. Confirm maintenance responsibility, snow access and emergency access before purchase.

Seasonal-home conversions

Some housing began as summer cottages and was expanded for year-round use. Buyers should verify permits, insulation, foundations, septic capacity and legal bedroom count.

Local real-estate services

Real Estate BrokerageRE/MAX Country Realty
1499 Union Valley Rd
West Milford, NJ 07480
973-248-5427
Real Estate BrokerageWerner Realty / The Werner Group
1465 Union Valley Rd
West Milford, NJ 07480
973-390-0583
Real Estate BrokerageCascade Real Estate LLC
1467 Union Valley Rd
West Milford, NJ 07480
862-686-8251
Mortgage / BankingProvident Bank
1527 Union Valley Rd
West Milford, NJ 07480
973-728-7780

Standard free commercial listings do not include private business website links.

Official property resources

Real-estate advertising on NJTGO

Agents, lenders, inspectors, attorneys and property-service businesses can request enhanced paid placement.

Advertising & Enhanced Listings

Market indicators reviewed September 2026 from Zillow and Realtor.com. Verify a property's value, taxes, utilities, flood status, lake obligations, septic/well condition and legal use independently.