Historic inn restaurant & bar
Crossed Keys Inn
Historic Main Street inn serving seasonal comfort food and local beer, with lodging upstairs.
Andover Borough Food & Drink
A municipality-tight guide to current dining on Main Street and Lenape Road, with carefully supported GF and DF filtering.
Eat in Andover Borough
The borough’s dining scene is compact and centered primarily on Main Street and Lenape Road. The list below stays within the borough instead of borrowing restaurants from the much larger Andover Township mailing area.
Pizza & Italian
IL Gusto Pizzeria & Italian
Family-run pizzeria with pizza, Italian-American dishes, takeout and catering.
Coffee & breakfast
Dunkin’
Coffee, espresso drinks, donuts and breakfast items at the current Andover Main Street location.
Pizza & Italian
Vinny & Son Pizza & Restaurant
GF
Pizza, Italian specialties, takeout and catering; the current menu includes gluten-free pizza choices.
Diner
Andover Diner
GF
Classic New Jersey diner serving breakfast through dinner; the current menu offers gluten-free bread and other gluten-free substitutions.
Bakery & café
Cafe Pierrot Andover Bakery
GFDF
French-inspired bakery, coffee, desserts and grab-and-go fare; current offerings include gluten-free bakery items and specifically identified dairy-free items.
Breakfast & lunch café
Lake House Cafe
GF
Coffee, breakfast and lunch in a historic grist-mill setting; current local menu coverage identifies vegetarian and gluten-free options.
GF / DF caution: Badges mean current menu or business information supports at least one gluten-free or dairy-free choice. They do not mean the kitchen is dedicated allergen-free, celiac-safe or free from cross-contact. Cafe Pierrot itself notes gluten-free production is not necessarily in a gluten-free facility. Anyone with an allergy or medical dietary need should confirm ingredients and preparation directly before ordering.
7 current in-borough food and drink businesses are included. 4 have current GF-supported choices and 1 has a current DF-supported choice based on information reviewed in September 2026.
Free directory listings identify local businesses and locations. Private business website links and enhanced promotional placement are available through NJTGO advertising.
Advertising information →